Notice of motion – Investigate Establishing an Affordable Housing Contribution Scheme
At next Tuesday’s meeting I will be raising a motion calling on Councillors to endorse the creation of an Affordable Housing Contribution Scheme, a tool an increasing number of Councils in NSW are using to require property developers to contribute towards the development of affordable housing within our Local Government Area.
There will be those that try to present this as big and scary or too ambitious, but the truth is this is a policy lever the State Government is encouraging Councils to use. And given the position TRC is in with Tamworth being a major growing regional centre with housing shortages that are only forecast to get worse into the future, I think we could use a bit of ambition.
What is an Affordable Housing Contribution Scheme?
Tamworth, as the capital of the New England North West, has Tamworth Regional Council well placed to implement initiatives to boost affordable housing supply. Given our established current shortfall of affordable dwellings, our projections of growth as a major regional centre (including the future need for student accommodation relating to the UNE campus development), and our unique incoming challenges as a service base for the development of the New England REZ.
As the level of government closest to the people they represent, local councils are at the forefront of dealing with this fallout and can make use of effective tools to tackle housing affordability and supply. I’m suggesting that we do this via introducing an Affordable Housing Contribution Scheme (AHCS). Councils can alter their planning policies to require developers to pay contributions towards affordable housing as part of their development consent.
These contributions can be in the form of the allocation of land within a proposed development to be used for constructing affordable housing, or the payment of a monetary contribution to be used for the purpose of providing affordable housing, or both.
Councils can only impose reasonable contributions, having regard to the extent of the need in the area for affordable housing, the scale of the proposed development, and what other contributions the developer is required to make. The State Government typically requires some modelling or a feasibility report that shows that an applying Council has thought about this question. That is, modelling that shows that property development margins will remain profitable after the addition of an AHCS is included in their development costs.
It’s also worth noting that the NSW Government has announced that every Local Government in Greater Sydney will be required to have an affordable housing contribution scheme in place by 2027. While the current focus of the State Government in this area appears to be on metropolitan councils, it’s reasonable to expect that this will eventually expand to become a requirement for Regional Councils, particularly regional centres and those with projections of growth.
The Need For Increased Affordable Housing Stock
The nation is in a housing crisis, and our region hasn’t been spared. In the Tamworth Region, low-income, and increasingly middle-income, residents in our community are finding it difficult to access housing that is affordable and/or appropriate to their needs. This has an unacceptable human impact, with people in our community facing constant housing uncertainty and financial stress, something that Local Government should always be considering in our decision-making.
It also has flow-on effects to other types of accommodation. Tamworth has a long-standing issue of a shortage of short-stay accommodation options, which is heightened by short-stay options like hotel rooms being utilised as crisis accommodation for victims fleeing domestic violence and people experiencing homelessness due to a lack of other housing options.
Further, it also impacts on our local economies. Many workers cannot find housing or cannot work to their full potential because they are under housing stress. A common issue Councillors hear from the business community is that with the city growing and local unemployment estimated to be sitting around 2%, they can’t recruit new workers to the region with required skills because of the lack of housing options available. Addressing our lack of affordable housing looks to the future of the region by making sure workers can afford to live here.
Towards the end of the last term of Council, TRC adopted the Tamworth Regional Housing Strategy 2024 which outlines various trends, issues, and goals for housing stock within the LGA. The document can be found here, and it’s well worth a read:
https://haveyoursay.tamworth.nsw.gov.au/housing-strategy
But in particular, for the purpose of this motion I want to focus on Priority Area 3 in the Strategy: Improve housing affordability and reduce housing costs. As outlined in the Strategy:
“Providing affordable rental housing is a distinct issue, separate from house prices and building costs. Many developers are not incentivised to build affordable rental housing as they do not provide a very high return on investment, especially in regional areas. With the State Government focused on the delivery of social housing, there is a significant gap in the delivery of affordable housing in the Tamworth region.
The provision of social and affordable rental housing is of critical importance with 1,150 (4.9%) households at the 2021 census in need of affordable housing, of which 168 persons (0.7%) were identified as homeless as shown in ABS data below.”

Although we thankfully have marginally lower levels of homelessness compared to the regional NSW average, we do have higher levels of rental stress (30% of the gross household income being spent on rent). It’s worth noting that in our region, the majority of people in housing stress are renters.
“In 2021, of the 25,341 households in the Tamworth Regional LGA, there were 2,165 households (8.5%) experiencing housing stress. This is dominated by the 1,651 households in rental stress as shown below in Figure 14.”

It’s also worth noting that TRC’s Housing Strategy sits under the larger State Government plan for the wider region, the New England North West Regional Plan 2041, which also contains Objective 14: Provide more affordable and low-cost housing.
What Form Could An Affordable Housing Contribution Scheme Take?
The motion is calling for Councillors to commit to investigating an AHCS to meet our adopted commitments of boosting affordable housing supply to address the amount of residents living in housing stress within our region, as well as generally increasing affordable housing supply. Although I have personal suggestions, I’m intentionally not asking fellow Councillors to approve a pre-developed AHCS, but rather to commit to the process of developing a scheme that considers localised needs and approaches. Taking this approach would also bolster our case with the State Government for a planning proposal to implement a potential scheme.
While we look to take further steps and develop a scheme, there are various considerations that will need to be taken into account. Such as:
How much affordable housing are we wanting to achieve?
What percentage of affordable housing would we want to achieve overall across our LGA or across Tamworth City? And considering that, what percentage of affordable housing would we want to see in new subdivisions?
Do we want buildings or a developer contribution, or a mix?
An AHCS could require a set percentage of dwellings in a new development to be dedicated to affordable housing. Alternatively, we could require developers to make a contribution to Council to fund affordable housing initiatives. We can also do a mixture of these two options, e.g. giving developers a choice to either directly build affordable housing or pay a contribution as an alternative.
Would it apply to residential or commercial development, or both?
In other Councils where an AHCS has been implemented, they may only be on new housing stock, but others also apply the scheme to commercial development. If Councils choose to do this they can also apply different rates to these different types of development. This is something we could consider implementing.
Would it apply to only new developments or renovations as well?
This is another option we could consider. It appears that in Councils that do both, in both cases a contribution is only required when a development is a certain size.
Would we apply a flat rate, or try and capture more if a building is rezoned to create more density?
In addition to the above regarding potentially including renovations in the scheme, as well as a flat rate for existing buildings being renovated, if there is a planning proposal for more height or density, we could consider capturing an additional contribution to reflect this densification. Although a large amount of our development is on greenfield sites, this is something that will become more relevant to us as we continue to promote infill development and shop-top housing. Councils that utilise this practice tend to require somewhere between 2% and 15%. This is referred to as “Value Uplift Capture”.
Where would the scheme apply?
Looking at examples of other Council areas where this is implemented, Blacktown City Council has a scheme that applies everywhere in the LGA, with a 1% levy. The City of Sydney applies everywhere, with a 3% levy. Most schemes only apply in target areas though, e.g. a new growth area or the CBD of their LGA. With ourselves being a large regional Council, we would have various options to consider, although I would recommend focusing on growth areas of Tamworth City. Councils can also apply different rates in different parts of their LGA.
What kind of affordable housing would we deliver, and for who?
Councils get to write a policy which outlines what kind of affordability or housing will be delivered by an AHCS. A common utilisation is to fund Community Housing Providers housing for people on low incomes. At Waverley Council they fund housing for people with a disability. At Byron Shire they are putting money aside to build Council housing, potentially for council workers being priced out of the area. At Willoughby City they fund housing for “key workers” like healthcare professionals. All of these are options we may wish to consider.
Will the housing be permanently affordable?
Would we want affordable housing supply created to have a defined time period of being allocated as affordable stock, or require it to remain affordable stock into perpetuity?
How are other Councils utilising an Affordable Housing Contribution Scheme?
Examples of recent affordable housing levies established or proposed by other Councils include:
Randwick City Council: affordable housing contribution in the city centre is 5% of the total floor area of the development used for residential purposes.
Byron Shire Council: up to 30% contribution uplift rate for greenfield investigation areas, and a 6% for residential and 2% for non-residential total gross floor area in the Byron Bay Town Centre.
Inner West Council: 50% of the increase in residual land value from value uplift.
City of Parramatta Council: developer contributions equivalent to 50% of the land value uplift outside of the CBD, with 10% of the value uplift to go towards affordable housing.
—
The text of the motion I’m raising is copied below. But for more on what I think TRC should be focusing on when it comes to housing, see this link:
https://ryanbrooke.au/housing/
Motion Title: Investigate establishing an Affordable Housing Contribution Scheme
Motion:
That Council:
(i) Note that the provision of social and affordable rental housing is identified as an action of critical importance under Priority 3 of the Tamworth Regional Housing Strategy 2024.
(ii) Note that Local Councils can require affordable housing contributions to be paid when development or rezonings are being undertaken in their local government area.
(iii) Investigate creating an Affordable Housing Contribution Scheme to facilitate the creation of affordable housing stock within our local government area.
(iv) Request a future report on a draft Affordable Housing Contribution Scheme be presented to Council for review.