Skip to main content Scroll Top

My statement on Cr Rodda’s censure (and Councillors using social media)

I wanted to wait until the minutes of our 11/03/25 meeting were released to make sure that anything I say here falls into what has been publicly disclosed. Late last week when Councillors received our version of the meeting business paper including confidential matters, we found out about a code of conduct investigation about a social media post made by Cr Rodda during last year’s local government election campaign where he outlined various things residents had told him were issues for them, that he would work to address if re-elected.

Several staff made complaints about commentary made in the post last August, and in response Council hired an external agency to do an investigation. I can’t get into the contents of that investigation report itself as it’s not public, but the outcome was that the investigator substantiated that Mark breached the Councillor Code of Conduct in regards to two comments made in the post relating to commentary on staff, and that he recommended Mark be censured as an appropriate course of action to take. Councils can resolve to take one of two courses of action when a substantiated breach of the code of conduct by Councillors has progressed from an investigation to coming before council. First is to censure, second is to censure and refer the matter to the office of local government (OLG) for further review.

I’ve seen some confusion between a censure and censoring. So for clarity, a censure is an expression of strong disapproval. In a Council setting, a motion to censure is a formal recording of that disapproval. When we got to that item of business earlier in the week, Cr Budd instead moved an alternative motion that we also refer the code of conduct matter to the OLG, and this was seconded by Cr North.

The resolution passed is pretty wordy, but it is as follows:

That in relation to the report “Code of Conduct Matter”, Council:

(i) Not adopt the investigator’s recommendation to formally censure Cr Rodda for the breach under section 440G of the Act due to the seriousness of the breach that warrants further penalties to be considered by the Office of Local Government;

(ii) Under Section 7.58 of the Procedures for the Administration of the Code of Conduct, Council formally censure Cr Rodda for the breach under section 440G of the Local Government and that the matter be referred to the Office of Local

Government for further action under the misconduct provisions of the Local Government Act;

(iii) Under Section 7.59 of the Procedures for the Administration of the Code of

Conduct the grounds on which Council is satisfied that the Councillor should be censured are:

  • Allegation 1 – On or about 1 August 2024, Cr Rodda placed a post on his

Facebook page that contained comments which could be seen as a personal attack on council staff and offensive and humiliating to them (particulars A and

B). Additionally, the comments had the potential to bring disrepute to council staff and the Council as a whole (all particulars).

  • The comments from the Facebook post comprising the particulars of this allegation are as follows:

(A) ‘Size of Council’s “Comms” team aka The Ministry of Public Enlightenment and Propaganda’.

(B) ‘Out of touch elected councillors and senior council staff’.

  • The finding of allegation 1 is found to be substantiated (in relation to particulars A and B).
  • The substantiated allegation constitutes a breach of the Code of Conduct pursuant to the following clauses:

3.1 You must not conduct yourself in a manner that:

(a) is likely to bring the council or other council officials into disrepute.

3.6 You must not harass or unlawfully discriminate against others.

3.7 For the purposes of this Code, “harassment” is any form of behaviour towards a person that:

(a) is not wanted by the person;

(b) offends, humiliates or intimidates the person; and

(c) creates a hostile environment.

7.6 You must not engage in any of the following inappropriate interactions:

(h) Councillors and Administrators making personal attacks on Council staff or engaging in conduct towards staff that would be contrary to the general conduct provisions in Part 3 of this Code in public forums including social media.

8.28 You must not use social media to post or share comments, photos, videos, electronic recordings or other information that:

(a) is offensive, humiliating, threatening or intimidating to other Council officials or those that deal with Council.

I’ve had a few people get in contact with me over the last few days asking how I voted. I did vote in favour of the motion. For my part, I thought Mark’s post was largely covered under the freedom of political expression (more about that in a bit), but I did think he made a mistake with the comment about the Communications team in particular. Mark and I have talked about this both before and after the item went to the Council meeting, and I believe he appreciates my thoughts on it.

Most of Mark’s post was a critique in the full post was of other Councillors (from the previous term), or Council as a collective org, which is fair game in my view. My belief is that as politicians we absolutely have the right, and I would go as far as saying the responsibility, to critique policy decisions and actions we disagree with. I also believe that as politicians, we have all put our hands up to be in the public eye and have to expect to be open to public scrutiny because of that.

But staff are private citizens doing their jobs. Mark’s comment, aside from the comparison made which I condemn, I think was loose enough that it crossed the line of being a critique of Council as a whole to being critical of a specific department of which individual staff felt they were being personally criticised. The investigation similarly found that the two parts of the post mentioning staff directly (as seen in the motion above) to be substantiated as a breach of the code of conduct, but not the remainder of the post.

I hope people can appreciate there’s a line there that I think we as Councillors need to be conscious of. “The park maintenance isn’t up to standard”, and “The work done by the park maintenance crew isn’t up to standard” can be read in two very different ways. Both could be written with the intention of making a criticism of operational priority, but one is also having a go at staff just doing their job. That’s something Councillors need to be on the lookout for in our own language.

I won’t comment on debate around the table during the item in closed council, other Councillors can share their thoughts if they are inclined to do so, but for myself I expressed that although I was uncomfortable with not having the opportunity to vote on the recommendation from the external investigator as an alternative motion was moved, I couldn’t in good faith vote to do nothing in response to the investigation.

On a different note, I guess consider this a stand-in for my usual “How Did Your Council Vote” post, which I didn’t make for this meeting as all items on the business paper were carried unanimously.

Thoughts on Social Media Use by Councillors

People tend to keep reading my long winded posts, so while I have your attention I thought I would publicly share my thoughts on what has been a constant internal debate amongst Councillors, and that’s the use of Social Media to communicate with residents.

The predominant view amongst Councillors seems to be that social media is something to be avoided, or a necessary evil. I disagree with that. I touched on it a bit in my end of year wrap up post last year, but I get why. People are mean through a keyboard and/or with the ability to be anonymous. But communication is a two-way street, and if we’re going to get good and constructive feedback from social media we need to shift our mindset to putting good content in and not just wanting reaffirmation for whatever we may post.

People will be upset by my vote in relation to Mark’s censure. I know that, but I made this post because I think residents deserve explanation behind the thought process that guided my decision. I’ll cop criticism for it, but that’s fair. Hopefully after reading this post you’ll understand my rationale, even if you disagree with it. It’s the same way Mark and I remain mates, we discussed it.

If you have feedback for me, I’ll read it. Your thoughts might give me a perspective to take with me into the future to hopefully make a better elected rep. Not all feedback Councillors get is gold by any stretch, but the gold is there. And often it happens in a message rather than a comment, a message that probably wouldn’t have been sent if I didn’t engage with the platform.

If I avoided social media and not commenting on such a high profile matter, I think that compounds the negative. Especially with the nature of this matter requiring it to be discussed in closed council. Without explanation, people are left to fill in the blanks. And with a lack of communication from Councillors, I can’t fault people for assuming malice. This isn’t a new issue, and it’s why transparency is always promised by candidates every Council election.

That’s why I think we should be embracing social media. And why I go to the effort to do my summaries of the briefing paper and meeting round-up posts. Social media can be an incredibly effective tool to open lines of communication with residents. But I think the onus is on us as elected representatives to use the tool effectively and build the rapport.

The Councillors who I think actively do this are myself, Marc Sutherland and, whether you like the tone of his posts or not, Mark Rodda. There is a reason Mark has such a large support base (and first preference vote margin). None of us always get it right (case in point, see above). But I hope one of the results of this code of conduct matter is an uptick in us using social media better, rather than seeing this as a reason to double down in avoiding it.

The irony of Mark’s code of conduct and this write up being so focused on social media, while also stemming from comments from the communications team isn’t lost on me. The last point I’ll make is that public communications is one area of Council where councillors intrinsically have a disproportionate amount of influence given that we are the public face and spokespeople for Council in a lot of situations. If we are going to change the trajectory of not just our council, but local government as a sector, to build trust in our institutions, an important building block of that is Councillors making effective use of the tools available to them and building their own communications networks.