Skip to main content Scroll Top

Tonight on Council – 11/08/2026

It’s a relatively light meeting in terms of agenda items this fortnight, but there are a few environmental issues I have opinions about that I would like to go into detail on.

Environment and Planning

Item 6.1 – Tamworth Regional Precinct Advisory Committees – Appointment of Additional Community Members

Earlier in the term, when we voted on the terms of reference of the Precinct Committees, one of the suggestions that I received from the community that I was happy to get included was dedicated positions for youth members of our region’s outlying communities. However, the expressions of interest received for the Precinct Committees weren’t sufficient to fill all eligible spots across the four committees (although it did vary), and this included the youth spots, for which only one EOI was received.

Because of this, when councillors voted to accept community members onto these committees back in December last year, we also resolved to undertake another EOI call with a focus in particular on younger community members for the youth spots. Honestly, unfortunately, only two EOIs were received, but as a result this item is asking councillors to assign both respondents to their respective committees.

Former Youth Mayor Rory Davis has applied to be part of the Manilla Committee, and Kyiah Holland has applied to be part of the Kootingal/Moonbi/Bendemeer Committee, which is the only committee to currently have another youth member, outgoing Youth Councillor Edward Blyton.

Item 6.2 – Proposed Road Name for Un-named Council Road Off Nundle Road, Dungowan – RN2026-0141

Item 6.2 is a pretty simple request for councillors to approve in principle the name Starbush Lane for an unnamed council road which extends north-east from the intersection of Nundle and Ogunbil Roads, Dungowan. The road name ‘Starbush’ is named after the Dungowan Starbush, a gazetted critically endangered plant only known from locations around Dungowan Dam.

As is the standard process with new road names, if approved in principle by Councillors, the name will be advertised, and if no negative submissions are received, the name will move on to being gazetted.

Item 6.3 – Calala Battery Energy Storage System Draft Voluntary Planning Agreement

The Calala Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) was approved as a State Significant Development in June 2024, with Equis Energy as the proponent. TRC has been negotiating a Voluntary Planning Agreement (VPA) with Equis since August 2024, when in-principle agreement was reached on the key terms: a monetary contribution of 0.31% of the finalised Capital Investment Value, to be paid as a lump sum within 20 business days of executing the agreement, currently valued at $1,397,000, plus a separate Community Benefit Fund of $200,000 per annum indexed to CPI for the first three years of operation, totalling $600,000. The combined benefit-sharing value is $1,997,000. This VPA was originally considered to be placed on public exhibition at our 12 May 2026 meeting. See item 6.1 at this link for more details:

https://ryanbrooke.au/tonight-on-council-12-05-2026/

At that meeting, Councillors resolved to place the Draft VPA on public exhibition, but Cr Sharpham moved an alternative motion at that meeting that clause 7.1.1 be omitted from the exhibited version. That clause reads:

“Not less than 20% of the Developer’s Contribution must be used to deliver agreed projects for First Nations communities in consideration of Closing the Gap and the Mara Ngali Partnership Agreement.”

Based on the current contribution amount of $1,397,000, that 20% allocation would represent a minimum of $279,400 directed towards First Nations community outcomes.

Following the May 2026 resolution to omit the clause, the project proponent, Equis Energy, wrote to TRC in June 2026 requesting that clause 7.1.1 be retained, on the basis that the commitment to First Nations community benefit forms part of its broader obligations under the Commonwealth’s Capacity Investment Scheme, and that the clause has formed part of the negotiated VPA terms throughout the drafting process up until it came before councillors to vote on it. Equis has indicated that omitting the clause could jeopardise the VPA proceeding, in which case the alternative contribution pathway under the development consent would apply. That alternative pathway essentially drops development contributions to the lower requirement under legislation, estimated to be worth approximately $1,350,000 over a 25-year operation, notably less than the VPA and without the $600,000 Community Benefit Fund component.

There’s also a timing pressure in that the Planning Secretary has approved an extension to the VPA execution deadline, but the agreement can’t be executed later than 18 September 2026, leaving little time for further drafting changes before the deadline.

The report presents councillors with three options. The first, and the one staff recommend, is to retain clause 7.1.1 in its originally negotiated form, reversing the May 2026 direction to omit it, and proceed to public exhibition of the full Draft VPA. The second is to maintain the omission of clause 7.1.1, which would preserve TRC’s discretion over the full contribution but remove the defined First Nations allocation and potentially put the VPA at risk. The third is to retain the 20% First Nations allocation but remove the specific references to Closing the Gap and the Mara Ngali Partnership Agreement, using broader wording instead. The report notes, however, that option three would require further drafting and agreement with Equis before the revised agreement could proceed to exhibition, and given the 18 September deadline, it may not leave sufficient time.

Infrastructure and Services

Item 7.1 – Tamworth Local Transport Forum – 1 July 2026

Item 7.1 is to update councillors and the public alike about the recommendations agreed to at the July meeting of the Tamworth Local Transport Forum. As always, I would recommend having a read of the meeting minutes in the business paper annexures to see a full list of items agreed to. But amongst the requests for event road closures, line markings and new signage approved, the most significant would have to be the various traffic management controls surrounding the Windmill Hill Commercial Centre in Moore Creek/North Tamworth.

Item 7.2 – Nundle State Forest Harvesting on Land Managed by Council

TRC has received correspondence from the Forestry Corporation of NSW advising that harvesting and haulage operations are planned for the Nundle State Forest commencing in late 2026, expected to take up to four months to complete. The planned harvesting program will include some Crown Land dedicated to State Forest that is managed by TRC. Specifically, TRC manages six Crown Land sites dedicated to State Forest in the Dungowan Dam Catchment, and the proposed harvesting areas fall within some of those parcels.

The legal framework around Crown Land is pretty complicated, but essentially the Crown Land parcels are subject to Perpetual Leases with specific conditions: the underlying land remains Crown Land managed as State Forest, Forestry Corp retains responsibility for forest management and timber operations, and forestry operations may continue within the leased areas subject to lease conditions and environmental regulatory requirements. Under those conditions, TRC cannot refuse to allow the harvesting operations to proceed.

TRC is entitled to a third of all net royalty income from timber harvested from the leased areas it manages. Forestry Corp cannot provide an estimate of that income before the harvesting commences. Given that the Water Reserve funds the charges and activities associated with the lease, the recommendation from staff is that any royalty income received will be directed to the Water Reserve.

So, it’s probably not a surprise that I’m not happy about this item. While I acknowledge the report’s advice that TRC doesn’t have the ability to refuse native timber logging operations, that doesn’t mean that as a council we have to be happy about it. And I would argue supporting this item would provide implicit approval, in the sense of being happy to receive an unspecified amount of royalties from it.

Notably, the report states that Forestry Corp cannot provide an estimate of the expected income prior to the harvesting works commencing, but this makes no sense. Surely Forestry Corp has planned the method and intensity of its logging operations, but no detail of this has been provided in the report. In fact, Forestry Corp has to give public notice of its logging operations ahead of carrying them out, but this hasn’t happened yet either, and as far as I can tell, this is the first public notice of this logging activity in these parcels of land.

This raises the question: has TRC been provided this information? And if we don’t have this information, shouldn’t we be seeking it? The report includes a public annexure detailing the perpetual lease conditions, and mentions correspondence received from Forestry Corp, but this hasn’t been provided. I’ve asked for a copy of this correspondence to be shared in the public annexures (or if it is considered to be confidential, to be shared with councillors directly), and have asked council staff if more details about this logging operation can be provided, but as of the time of writing this post those requests remain unanswered.

But this information is important. Have these areas been logged previously? If so, was it selective felling or more wide-scale? It seems unlikely, considering these parcels of land are rather steep slopes and well established. If there hasn’t been, this makes the biodiversity value of this forested area all the more valuable. The recently completed Tamworth Region Biodiversity Baseline Study identifies this area of our LGA to be the most strategically important biodiverse landscape we have. This correspondence should contain information about what ecological communities and wildlife this forest provides habitat to. Has any consideration been given to this by TRC?

Even if the amount of native timber to be extracted is small, how does that weigh up against the risk of increased erosion? Historically, a vast amount of silt has washed into Dungowan Dam; disturbing the forest again could lead to more sedimentation.

The report states that Forestry Corp claims its practices support ecologically sustainable forest management. But it’s a well-known fact that logging forests over time results in reduced habitat for threatened species dependent on tree hollows, and increases fire impact.

Putting aside the issues with the carbon sequestration credit market for a moment, and considering the proposed renewable energy projects and powerline infrastructure in the vicinity of Nundle State Forest that have rightfully been criticised for the vegetation clearing they require, wouldn’t Nundle State Forest and the surrounding council-owned land be worth more to preserve and enhance, to offset the impacts of other nearby works?

Even if we can’t say no to Forestry Corp’s actions as a Local Government, have any lobbying efforts against native hardwood logging been considered, given that councillors haven’t been consulted?

If you’ll indulge me to divert from council issues for a moment, you should know that despite the mention of royalties payable to council in the report, native forest logging isn’t profitable. In fact, public money subsidises Forestry Corp’s clearing operations. As an industry, it has lost $90 million since 2020 and is only propped up by taxpayer subsidies, despite an estimated 70% of people in NSW opposing native forest logging and around 90% of all timber production already coming from plantations, and of the hardwood that is logged, at least half is used for woodchip and paper production.

Victoria, Western Australia, and South Australia have already banned native forest logging, and the evidence is that it isn’t ecologically, socially, or financially viable. Personally, I would rather taxpayer money went towards a just transition out of the native timber industry, rather than propping it up.

If you would like to support calls to ban native forest logging in NSW, check out the links below:

https://www.forestalliancensw.org.au/end-native-logging

https://www.suehigginson.org/loggingtimeup

Item 7.3 – Pedestrian Safety Improvements – Jack Smyth Drive Median

TRC has received funding from Transport for NSW’s (TfNSW) Road Safety Program to deliver pedestrian safety improvements at three locations in the Sports and Entertainment Precinct. One of those locations is the roundabout at Jack Smyth Drive and The Ringers Road, in front of the Australian Equine and Livestock Events Centre. Contracts for civil works, lighting upgrades and pedestrian safety fencing were endorsed by Councillors in late 2025.

This report deals with a specific issue that has emerged during the design process: that the existing mounded vegetation in the Jack Smyth Drive median between The Ringers Road and the New England Highway doesn’t comply with current road design standards for sight lines. The originally approved design (Option 1) would remove all vegetation, level the mound running down the median strip, and replace the entire median with turf. When this was flagged with Councillors, some of us raised issues with this, so additional options were developed, and this item is to present those options for one to be endorsed.

Four options are presented in the report. As explained above, Option 1 is to fully strip all existing vegetation and replace it with grass along the median. Option 2, which is the staff recommendation, removes all vegetation and the raised mound but establishes three feature garden beds within the turfed median, transplanting some of the existing plants such as the grass trees where possible. The roundabout would have its vegetation removed and a smaller central garden replanted with transplanted or matching species. Option 3 would retain approximately 75 metres of the existing mounded vegetation in the central portion of the median. Option 4 is to do nothing, which would likely result in TfNSW withdrawing the project funding and TRC being required to return approximately $200,000 already spent.

I was one of the councillors who flagged issues with removing the established grass trees and shrubs along Jack Smyth Drive. To me, having native, beneficial plants lining any road median, especially a major and important avenue, is going to be better than plain grass that does nothing for biodiversity, requires mowing, and is going to die as soon as it gets dry anyway. It’s an easy decision.

For me, Option 3 is the most preferable. TfNSW is requiring some of the existing vegetation to be removed for safety upgrades, which is fair enough, but I think the arguments put forward against Option 3 don’t add up. Weeds and “unwanted self-propagation” of plants are given as issues with the current median, but grass is also going to come with weed issues, arguably more so than a mulched median. But if weeds are an issue, I would argue the way to counteract them is to densify the plantings in the area and crowd the weeds out with plantings. Option 2 states that existing plants would be transplanted, where possible, from the area required to be cleared for sight lines; I’d suggest doing this for Option 3 as well, and putting more plants in.

TRC has been doing well in working towards getting trees in the ground and increasing urban tree canopy coverage (and the work of former Councillor Helen Tickle needs to be acknowledged here), but I would argue something we need to get better at is more rounded urban greening, and bushes and ground cover are important parts of that. And I think Jack Smyth Drive would be a great test case for resilient rewilding in urban areas: hotspots of urban biodiversity that are naturally resilient to our region’s harsh conditions due to using native vegetation, rather than just another plain strip of half-dead grass.

Governance, Strategy and Finance

Item 8.1 – Sundry Debtor Write Off for 2025/2026

To round out the meeting, this item is a request, as we’re now in the 2026/27 financial year, to write off $141,245.59 in debts owed to TRC that are considered uneconomical to recover ($1,653.10), or that have had the legal grounds to recover exhausted (the vast bulk of the amount at $139,592.49). If approved, the balance of outstanding receivables will be expensed in the current financial year.

This is a common item to come before councils around the end of a financial year. Councillors have been provided a list of the individuals and businesses whose debt is proposed to be written off, and the amount and details of the debt, in a confidential enclosure. Because those details are confidential, though, I frustratingly can’t comment much on this item.

Closed Council

Item 11.1 – Acceptance of Out of Region Residual Dry Waste at Tamworth Waste Management Facility – Outcome of Negotiations With iQRenew Group

This item is a follow-up to the decision made at the 28 July 2026 meeting (in open council), where Councillors approved acceptance of residual dry waste from iQRenew Group’s Somersby Material Recovery Facility at the Forest Road Waste Management Facility, subject to EPA licence approval and confirmation of waste levy arrangements, with a 50% out-of-region surcharge applied.

Following that resolution, council staff formally advised iQRenew of the approved terms. iQRenew has since indicated it does not accept the 50% surcharge and has declined to proceed on those terms. The only other information provided in the public business paper is that this item is seeking direction from Councillors on how to proceed with further negotiations, or not.