Tonight on Council – 25/08/2025
We’re back from a 2-week break, and we have a pretty sizeable meeting agenda in front of us tonight including a decision on a new Medical Centre DA, the new social media policy, and potential changes to commercial developer charges. Get comfortable, this will be a long one
Notices of Motion and Questions with Notice
Item 6.1 – Cr Impey motion – Mental Health Summit of Local Mental Health Service Providers
Starting the meeting out we have a Notice of Motion being raised by Cr Impey, calling on council to commit to allocating resources to host a Mental Health Summit. With the intention that the summit would gain guidance from the community mental health services on the merit of establishing a new council committee in the form of a Mental Health Working Group to better advise and guide TRC’s action in the mental health advocacy space.
Mental health is something that Charles is incredibly passionate about, and I know he’s been working on this motion for a decent chunk of time now, as I’ve been discussing it with him for a while. And I’m very supportive of what he is proposing here. As Charles says in his supporting commentary, local government can (and I would argue should) play an important role in advocating for the improvement of mental health services across the Local Government Area (LGA).
Environment and Planning
Item 7.1 – Construction of a new Medical Centre, Wellbeing Centre and Allied Uses by Tamworth Aboriginal Medical Centre on land in Hyman Park, South Tamworth
The sole item in Environment and Planning tonight is an interesting decision regarding a Development Application (DA). Typically when a DA comes to councillors it will be to make a decision to approve it or not, but in this case we’re being asked to approve recommended conditions of consent to the Regional Planning Panel who are scheduled to make a decision on this DA in September. And to decide not to make a formal submission to the Regional Planning Panel.
The DA is for a new Medical Centre by Tamworth Aboriginal Medical Service (TAMS) on the southern side of Hyman Park in South Tamworth. And the DA is going to the Northern Regional Planning Panel (a State Government body that decides on regionally significant developments) for a determination both because the value of the development is over $5 million, and because TRC is the current landowner of the development site.
There is some significant history surrounding this development though that I will briefly recap. I will also say up front that I will be declaring a conflict of interest on this item and opting to not participate in debate or a vote, so I will not go into my personal thoughts on the development. My work is the IT provider for TAMS, and if this development goes ahead it would require TAMS to make a pretty large investment in IT infrastructure. So although it isn’t a direct pecuniary link to myself directly, I still think this is significant enough that I should exclude myself.
Back in December 2017 a report came to councillors requesting that council begin the process of splitting up Hyman Park on either side of Hillvue Road, with the south side of the park remaining zoned as community land, and the east side being re-zoned to operational land. This was in response to two separate organisations approaching council to purchase and build on the land. One was Fire and Rescue NSW, the other was TAMS. A further report came to councillors requesting to proceed with this in October 2018. Both of these reports were in open council.
After those resolutions of council though, things were sidetracked due to the COVID-19 pandemic, and Fire and Rescue NSW ended up moving ahead with a build in Hillvue instead. However TAMS remained interested in purchasing the land, and there has been discussion between TAMS and TRC since renewed talks in 2021.
TRC’s Assessment Report to the Northern Regional Planning Panel (which is included in the meeting annexures) recommends approving the development subject to the conditions of consent councillors are being asked to endorse in this item.
Infrastructure and Services
Item 8.1 – Options for Commercial Developer Charges
Back in June 2018 the council of the day adopted the current water and sewer development charges in line with the NSW Department of Primary Industries “2016 Developer Charges Guidelines for Water Supply, Sewerage and Stormwater”. The 2016 guidelines remain current to this day.
When adopting these charges, the resolution councillors at the time agreed to contained a point that they “request the Director Water and Waste investigate policy options that consider mitigation strategies on the impacts of Developer Service Charges on non-residential development in the service areas of Hills Plains and Arcadia”. But the request hasn’t happened since the item passed council until now.
I believe this has been followed up by some councillors hoping to remove barriers of commercial developments in Hills Plains. As a result the report in this item is to present options and explore the impact of those options, should councillors choose to change from the present charges for non-residential development in the service areas of Hills Plains and Arcadia in Tamworth, and to seek council’s direction about how to proceed.
Developer charges are just what they sound like, charges levied on developers to recover part of the infrastructure costs incurred by councils to provide town water and sewer services to new developments or cater for additional demand arising from changes to existing developments.
Currently across the LGA different developer charges are levied depending on the geographical service area the development is in. For instance currently water development charges Manilla, Barraba, Nundle, Attunga and Bendemeer are $646. Meanwhile Moonbi, Kootingal, and the majority of Tamworth are $4,848. But the Hills Plains development precinct in Moore Creek is $14,407, and the planned Arcadia development precinct is $10,960. The latter two being separated because they are a new development area of over 500 lots, and have other factors that make them more expensive to service.
The above prices are based on one Equivalent Tenement (ET). An ET is a unit of measurement that very oversimplified could be explained as effectively one residential house.
In regards to considering alternative options for how to levy developer charges, TRC is required to set charges in line with the 2016 NSW Government Guidelines aimed at meeting and balancing the needs of a wide range of customers, with the aim of establishing processes which facilitate fair, consistent and defensible decision making.
The main risk to council in not applying the methodology detailed in the Guidelines is should council be challenged on the developer charges and council has not followed the methodology detailed in the relevant NSW Government Guidelines, it is uncertain what that would mean for council’s ability to defend the charges levied.
All of which brings us up to three different suggested options that have been put forward by council staff for councillors to consider. Each option has been measured against a hypothetical example of a non-residential development to give an idea of what the impact of changes to developer charges would be. The example development has been calculated as placing a demand on water supply of eight ET, and demand on sewer of six ET.
Option 1
Option 1 is business as usual, not making any changes. This is the recommended option by council staff. Under this option the combined water and sewer developer charges for the example development would be: Hills Plains $146,402, Tamworth $49,694, Arcadia $130,652.
The advantages of option 1 is that TRC would continue to have a defensible methodology for levying developer charges, and would be compliant with the NSW Government’s Regulatory & Assurance Framework.
Option 2
Option 2 is to create a uniform non-residential developer charge across the identified areas (Tamworth, Hills Plains, Arcadia) using agglomeration. Agglomeration is a weighted average of charges, based on the Present Value of ETs to create a uniform charge across the three identified areas.
In effect this option would mean that non-residential development in any area of Tamworth not in the Arcadia or Hills Plains service area will increase to subsidise non-residential development in Arcadia and Hills Plains.
It’s also noted in the report that agglomeration of charges is specifically mentioned in the NSW Government Guidelines as being against the philosophy of the methodology. The guidelines state one of the functions of the different charges is to provide signals regarding the cost of urban development and by extension encourage less costly forms and areas of development. Agglomeration of charges on the other hand effectively causes locations that are more economical to develop to cross-subsidise less economical ones.
Under this option the combined water and sewer developer charges for the example development would be $86,363 across all areas. That equates to a reduction of $60,039 in Hills Plains, a reduction of $44,289 in Arcadia, and an increase of $36,669 in the rest of the Tamworth Service Area.
If someone was inclined to reduce the cost of non-residential development in Hills Plains and Arcadia this option would achieve that, but as a result non-residential development in the Tamworth Service area would be cross subsidising development in these new development areas. And it creates the mismatch that residential development will be charged differently to non-residential development in the three main service areas.
Option 3
Option 3 is to create a uniform non-residential developer charge across the identified areas (Tamworth, Hills Plains, Arcadia) equal to the lowest charge. So it’s similar to option 2, but instead of the cost of non-residential development charges being raised in the wider Tamworth service area to offset a reduction of development charges in Hills Plains and Arcadia, all developer charges would be brought in line with the lowest of the three, which is the wider Tamworth service area.
If this option was used, the shortfall of income would come from council’s other funding sources, including water and sewer charges paid by residential and commercial customers across the LGA, instead of the property developers at the time of development.
Under this option the combined water and sewer developer charges for the example development would be $49,694 across all areas. That equates to a reduction of $96,708 in Hills Plains, a reduction of $80,958 in Arcadia, and the developer charge in the rest of the Tamworth Service Area would not change.
It’s also stated in the report that if challenged, the levying of charges in this way is not in accord with the prescribed methodology referenced in the Act making it more difficult to justify or defend.
So for example, if we assume there will be 100 non-residential water and sewer ET developed over the next ten years. Under option two non-residential development in the Hills Plains Service area would receive a cross subsidy of $797,242 from development in the Tamworth service area. A non-residential development in the Arcadia Service area would receive a cross subsidy of $649,642 from development in the Tamworth service area. Under option 3, the non-residential development in Hills Plains and Arcadia service areas would receive a cross subsidy each of approximately $1.2 million from all customers paying water and sewer charges. Note that this calculation is based on current year’s charges only.
I’ve briefly summarised a really good report written by Naomi Schipanski who’s the Manager of Projects, Strategy and Infrastructure in the Water and Waste Directorate. She goes into a lot more detail, and provides the previous reports that went before council in 2018 which also provides some good background. So I would recommend reading her report in the business paper.
As for my opinions, I consider option 3 a non-starter. Increasing water and sewer access charges on residents to allow property developers to contribute less towards council’s infrastructure costs on development areas and maximise their profits isn’t something I think we should be seriously considering.
I also have major ssues with option 2. It’s raised in the report, but the methodology with the developer charges is that they are higher in areas where more capital investment into building headwork infrastructure is required. We’re talking about new greenfield developments (especially in the case of Arcadia since Hills Plains has progressed a lot over previous years). It makes sense to me that property developers should be fairly chipping in to facilitate these developments, but is increasing costs on a similar development in a more developed area to make it cheaper for developers in new areas fair?
Especially considering that in TRC’s own housing strategy we stress the need to increase density via infill developments to diversify our housing stock, instead of just continuing urban sprawl. This item is for non-residential development instead of residential, but an increase of commercial development will be downstream of increased residential infill development, and option 2 seems as if it would stifle that.
Overall I think this item also raises the question, what is the drive to introduce changes to developer charges? Is there an upside other than reducing the cost of non-residential development in Hills Plains and Arcadia, two areas that are predominantly residential developments. And would achieving this result be worth putting TRC in a precarious position of not being able to defend the methodology of the charges we’re trying to levy against State Government guidelines? And are we considering that residential developers in Hills Plains and Arcadia are undoubtedly going to want their developer charges lowered next?
Item 8.2 – New Dungowan Pipeline Ownership and Easement Acquisition
Similar to the report above item about developer charges, manager of Water and Environmental Operations, Daniel Coe, has written a really good and detailed report about the process that has been undertaken so far regarding the new Dungowan Dam Pipeline that was constructed by the State Government in recent years running between TRC’s Calala Water Treatment Plant (CWTP) and to the point where the Chaffey Dam Pipeline meets the existing Dungowan Dam Pipeline near the Dungowan Recreation Ground.
If you’re interested in what has happened with the State Government project to build the pipeline up until this point, I would recommend giving it a read. But this post has already gotten pretty long, so I’m going to skip over the background to where we are up to now.
The construction of the pipeline from the CWTP to the Dungowan Recreation Ground originally was going to constitute phase 1 of the now dead-in-the-water new Dungowan Dam project. Now that the new dam isn’t going ahead, in recent years work has been progressing to transfer ownership of the new section of the pipeline from the State Government to TRC. As part of that work, the State Government’s Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water (DCCEEW) is progressing with acquiring pipeline easements from affected landholders across the route.
This item is seeking councillors’ endorsement of the Negotiation Protocol (and other agreements as required) the DCCEEW is planning to use for easement acquisition, primarily the compensation offer terms and compensation value limits. Because of these figures the Negotiation Protocol has been included as a confidential enclosure for councillors.
It’s worth noting that the DCCEEW will be covering all costs of easement acquisition (with the exclusion of any council staff time requirements). Now that TRC is formally the asset owner of the pipeline TRC will have to make initial payments, but this will be reimbursed by the DCCEEW which is outlined in a Memorandum of Understanding that has been created with DCCEEW to facilitate the easement acquisition process.
Governance, Strategy and Finance
Item 9.1 – Social Media Policy
Onto what I think will be one of the items that will receive the most community attention tonight. Item 9.1 is a request to adopt TRC’s draft update to the Social Media Policy. And up until about a week ago I had a different, more negative write-up about this item.
Councillors voted to put the draft policy out to public exhibition at the end of April and it was open for community feedback from 8 May 2025 to 5 June 2025. During this time four submissions were received which have been provided to councillors to review, and some minor changes had been made as a result. Councillors have also had a workshop dedicated to discussing the draft policy before which I precirculated my own feedback and suggestions about the policy. No councillors, either present at the workshop or via email, had any issues with my feedback that was raised.
At our pre-meeting briefing (that we do a week before a council meeting so councillors can ask further questions about the upcoming business paper), I brought up that I feel like my suggestions haven’t been taken on board in the updated draft policy. And I ended up having some constructive conversations with council staff that led to the draft policy being updated to address my major issues with it.
Our draft Social Media Policy uses the State Government’s Model Social Media Policy for Councils as a base and the draft TRC Social Media Policy that was put out to community consultation was largely the same as the State Model Policy. For reference you can download the State Model Policy here:
https://www.olg.nsw.gov.au/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/Model-Social-Media-Policy.docx
The major part of my criticism of the State Model Policy is that the policy states in clauses 3.2, 7.1, and 7.3 that councillors are subject to the State Records Act 1998. This is contrary to advice I received from a lawyer colleague that, following the High Court decision in Re: Lambie in 2018, where it was definitively ruled that councillors are not holders of an office of profit under the Crown. Therefore, Local Government councillors are not specified in Section 3 of the State Records Act 1998, and by extension, posts by councillors are highly unlikely to be a State record even when commenting on the business of council.
I’ll grant that this is legally contestable. But given that it’s not clear that councillors are subject to the State Records Act, and the onerousness of this policy as written to require councillors to document, produce copies of, and securely back up and store records of not only all posts made by them, but all comments made on those posts by members of the public, and even private direct messages with community members. In many cases beyond the end of their term of council.
Thankfully following conversation I’ve had with council staff, these clauses in our policy have been altered to remove mention of the State Records Act 1998, and for the record-keeping requirements to be more reasonable.
Back in my “Tonight on Council” post for the 29 April meeting I said that I think the wording in the Model Policy, and by extension TRC’s draft policy, needing some tightening up to explicitly outline the differences between councillors’ responsibilities on their profiles as opposed to Council’s responsibilities on it’s profiles, but that the original draft policy was serviceable.
The draft policy coming to us for adoption I still think has sloppy wording in places. And there are omissions I would like to incorporate into our policy such as an acknowledgement on the importance of public comment, Councillors freedom of political communication, and councillors role under section 232 of the Local Government Act in facilitating communication between the local community and the governing body.
But acknowledging that I believe the majority of councillors in our body politic are happy with the new draft policy, and that I have been able to work with staff to champion some changes that I think have significantly improved it, it’s in a spot where I’m okay with it being adopted.
I’ll have more to say about this item tonight, but for now you can read more about my thoughts on the use of social media by councillors in my previous write-up about Cr Rodda’s code of conduct matter earlier in the year (which is very much the elephant in the room for this item) here:
https://ryanbrooke.au/my-statement-on-cr-roddas-censure-and-councillors-using-social-media/
You can view the updated draft policy in the meeting annexures on TRC’s website.
Rounding out this section of the business paper and the items to be discussed in open council is the July Council Investments report and a delegates report by the Executive Manager Creative Communities and Experiences, Peter Ross, about June Sister Cities Exchange Trip to Nashville, Tennessee that himself and Mayor Webb went on.
Closed Council
We have 6 separate items in closed council (where we vote on commercial confidential items) this meeting. The first two relate to parcels of land at the TRC subdevelopment at the Tamworth Global Gateway Park. Item 12.1 is seeking authorisation to negotiate and enter into a Contract for the Sale of Land of the lot at 1 Goddard Lane, Westdale. Item 12.2 is seeking authorisation to allocate an empty lot to the Water & Waste Directorate for the purpose of a proposed industrial hard plastics processing facility (which was an item that came up in closed council back at our 11/2/25 meeting).
Item 12.3 is to review tenders for the design, supply and installation of a telecommunication hut at a TRC water infrastructure site at One Tree Hill in South Tamworth. Currently, water and wastewater communications equipment is located in a water pump station building and due for upgrading, and the current building does not have space requirements to cater for planned upgrades. Sharing a building for the pump equipment also puts the communications equipment at risk of being damaged in the case of a pipe leak. Hence this plan to construct a dedicated telecommunications hut to house current and future communication equipment.
Speaking of water and wastewater infrastructure. Item 12.4 is review tenders for the removal and replacement of 10 sewer vents due for replacement located in Tamworth and Barraba. Item 12.5 is a report to inform councillors of the identified options available for the procurement and delivery of replacement aeration blowers at the Westdale Waste Water Treatment Plant.
Item 12.6 is an item to review submission regarding an expression of interest for land owned by council near Dungowan Dam for either lease or agistment.